Skip to content

All guides

Are dice fair when an AI runs the game?

It depends on who rolls the dice. If a normal chatbot says it rolls a d20, the dice are not really fair: the AI writes a number, and it often picks one that makes a good story. Dice are fair when the AI can only ask for a roll, and a separate program rolls the dice and applies the rules. That is how Role is Easy works.

  • Updated November 15, 2026

Why a chatbot is not a fair die

A language model writes text, one word after another. When you ask it to roll a die, it does not throw anything. It writes the number that seems right for the moment. Some chatbots even say this when you ask them.

This causes three problems. First, the numbers are not really random. Players often notice that chatbot rolls succeed too often, or fail at the most dramatic moment. Second, the AI can make mistakes when it adds bonuses. Third, players can push it. If you complain about a bad roll, a chatbot may let you roll again, or simply change the result to please you.

None of this is cheating on purpose. The AI is trying to tell a good story and keep you happy. But a game with dice only feels real when the dice can say no.

What makes a dice roll fair

A fair roll in a tabletop game needs a few simple things. It does not matter if the dice are plastic or digital.

  • Every number has the same chance. On a d20, a 1 is as likely as a 20.
  • Nobody can choose the result. Not the players, and not the Game Master.
  • The rules are the same for everyone. The same roll with the same bonus gives the same result.
  • Everyone can see the roll. The number, the bonuses and the target are visible.
  • A bad roll counts. You cannot talk your way into a better number afterwards.

How Role is Easy keeps the dice honest

In Role is Easy, the job is split in two. The AI Game Master tells the story. A separate rules engine does the maths. The AI never controls the numbers.

When your character tries something risky, the Game Master asks for a check. It names the skill and how hard the task is. For example: "You need to roll a d20 for climbing, and you need 12 or more." You can also choose to try something different.

Then you throw the d20. The rules engine rolls it on the server, not in your browser and not inside the AI. It adds your attribute and your skill, and compares the total with the difficulty. The dice use a seeded random generator. This means the same inputs always give the same result, so the server can check every roll and play it back later.

Only after that does the Game Master tell you what happens. It describes the result that the rules engine gave. It cannot change it. To learn more about how the AI and the rules work together, read can an AI run a tabletop RPG.

You can see every roll

Fair dice also need to be visible. In Role is Easy, 3D dice roll on the shared table, where every player can see them at the same time.

After the roll, you see the full result: the number on the die, your bonuses, the total, and the number you needed. For example: "Success — rolled 9 + 4 = 13. Needed 12 or higher." Nothing is hidden behind the Game Master's words.

The rules also have clear edges. A natural 20 is always a critical success. A natural 1 is always a mishap, the worst result. This keeps the game exciting, and it is the same for every player.

Do you only need dice for a game at home or on a video call? Read how to roll dice online for tabletop RPGs. It explains our free 3D dice roller. If you are not sure what "d20" or "2d6" means, read dice notation explained.

Can you talk the AI into a better roll?

No. This is one of the main reasons for the split between the AI and the rules engine. The Game Master can only ask for a check. It cannot roll, and it cannot change your health, your equipment or a result.

So you can say anything to the Game Master. You can beg, argue or try a clever trick in the story. A clever plan can change what you try next, or make the task easier in the story. But once the dice land, the number stays. Your friends know that your success is real, and you know that theirs is real too.

Every result is also saved in the game record. The campaign journal keeps what happened, so the story later builds on the real result, not on a version someone liked better.

Try it with your group

You only need a browser and some friends. Webcams and microphones are optional, because you can also play by text. You say what your character does in your own words, and the dice decide the risky moments.

Look at campaigns other players have made, read what an AI Game Master is, or check the prices.

Questions and answers

Does ChatGPT roll real dice?

Not by itself. A normal chatbot writes a number that seems to fit the story. Unless it uses a separate dice tool, the result is not truly random, and it can change if you argue.

Can the AI Game Master in Role is Easy change a roll?

No. The AI can only ask for a check. The rules engine rolls the dice on the server and applies the rules. The AI then describes the result it was given.

Who decides when I need to roll?

The AI Game Master decides when an action is risky enough to need a roll. It names the skill and the number you need. You can also choose to try something else instead.

Are digital dice less fair than real dice?

Not if they are made well. Good digital dice give every number the same chance, and nobody at the table can push them. Real plastic dice can also be uneven, and a Game Master can hide a roll behind a screen.

Try it with your friends